Evolv Crate vs Soft-Sided Crate: Pros and Cons

Quick Answer

If you need a durable, chew-resistant crate that blends with your home and lasts through puppyhood, the Diggs Evolv crate is the stronger choice. Soft-sided crates are lighter and more portable, but they are not suitable for chewers or dogs that need a secure, escape-proof space. Choose based on your dog's temperament and your lifestyle.

Choosing between the Evolv crate and a soft-sided crate comes down to what matters most: durability and security versus portability and convenience. Both have their place, but they serve very different needs.

In this comparison, we'll break down the pros and cons of each type, using the Diggs Evolv crate as the reference for a rigid, multi-functional option. You'll also get practical fit guidance so you can make the right call for your dog.

Durability and Chew Resistance

The Evolv crate is built with a sturdy frame and mesh panels that are designed to withstand normal wear and tear. It's a rigid structure that holds its shape, making it much harder for a determined dog to bend or break out. Soft-sided crates, by contrast, are made of fabric and flexible poles. They are easy to collapse, but they are also easy to scratch, tear, or chew through.

If your dog is a chewer, a soft-sided crate is a risky choice. A single determined session can result in holes and a potential escape. The Evolv's rigid design offers peace of mind, especially for growing puppies or dogs that are still learning house rules.

• Check your dog's chewing habits before choosing a crate. If in doubt, go with a more durable option.

Ventilation and Visibility

The Evolv crate features mesh panels that allow for good airflow and visibility. Your dog can see out, and you can see in, which helps with bonding and monitoring. Soft-sided crates also have mesh windows, but the fabric sides can reduce airflow in warmer conditions, and the view is often more restricted.

Good ventilation is crucial for your dog's comfort, especially in warmer climates. The Evolv's mesh design helps keep air moving, reducing the risk of overheating. Soft-sided crates can feel stuffy, particularly if they are placed in a warm room or used in a car for extended periods.

• Consider the climate in your area. If summers are hot, prioritize crates with ample mesh ventilation.

Portability and Storage

Soft-sided crates win on portability. They fold flat and are lightweight, making them easy to carry to a friend's house, on a road trip, or to a camping site. The Evolv crate is more substantial; while it can be moved, it's not designed for frequent folding and unfolding. It's a more permanent fixture in your home.

If you travel often with your dog, a soft-sided crate might be more convenient. However, if you need a crate that stays in one place and serves as a reliable den, the Evolv's sturdiness is a clear advantage.

• Think about how often you'll move the crate. Frequent travelers may prefer a pop-up model.

Trade-Offs at a Glance

• Durability vs. Portability: The Evolv crate is rigid and sturdy, but it's not easily foldable. Soft-sided crates are lightweight and packable but offer little resistance to chewing or scratching. If you need a permanent home base, choose Evolv. If you need to move frequently, soft-sided is more practical.
• Ventilation vs. Insulation: The Evolv's mesh panels promote airflow, which is great in warm weather. Soft-sided crates may retain heat but can also provide a cozier, den-like feel in colder environments. Consider your local climate and your dog's temperature sensitivity.
• Security vs. Accessibility: The Evolv crate is more secure, reducing the risk of escape. Soft-sided crates are easy to open and close, but they can be unzipped by clever dogs or damaged by determined ones. For escape artists, the Evolv is the safer bet.

Product Facts

• Evolv Dog Crate: Evolv - S The Evolv crate is available in sizes, so you can choose the right fit for your dog. A properly sized crate is essential for comfort and safety.
• Bolstr Evolv Bed: Bolstr is a versatile dog bed with a bolstered headrest, designed to fit perfectly with our Evolv dog crate.Key Features: Durable and water repellent: Made with tough fabrics to resist scratching and chewing, with a water repellent outer cover to protect against accidents. Bolstered headrest: Provides a comfortable and supportive space for your dog to rest their head and neck, promoting better sleep and... Pairing the Evolv crate with the Bolstr bed adds a layer of comfort and protection. The water-repellent cover helps manage accidents, and the bolstered headrest supports restful sleep.

Which One Fits Your Dog?

Best for

• Dogs that are chewers or prone to scratching at their enclosure
• Owners who want a durable, long-term crate that blends with home decor
• Puppies that need a secure space for crate training and growth

Not for

• Travelers who need a lightweight, easily collapsible crate for frequent trips
• Owners with very limited storage space who need to pack the crate away when not in use

In the end, the right crate depends on your dog's personality and your daily routine. The Diggs Evolv crate offers superior durability, ventilation, and security, making it a solid investment for a home environment. Soft-sided crates are handy for travel and temporary setups, but they can't match the Evolv's resilience. Weigh the trade-offs, consider your dog's needs, and choose the crate that will keep them safe and comfortable for years to come.